5 Signs He’s a Peter Pan (And Why You Deserve a Grown Man)

September 25, 2025

Hi, I'm Jackie

I'm the head cheerleader for your love story, your new 'big sis' and wing woman - so if you're new to me, welcome to me, your love life will be better now. 

There’s a difference between dating a man who is still becoming and dating a man who is refusing to grow. The first has potential for partnership; the second will keep you stuck in cycles of immaturity, frustration, and heartbreak.

Too many women waste years trying to “mother” a Peter Pan, a man who loves playtime but resists maturity, accountability, and commitment. But you weren’t created to raise your partner. You were created to walk beside him.

Here are five signs you’re dating a Peter Pan and why it’s time to expect more.

1. Commitment Feels Like Captivity

If he flinches every time you bring up the future: labels, timelines, responsibility, it’s a sign he’s not ready to grow. To him, commitment isn’t an honor, it’s a trap. A man who views partnership as a prison will never treat you as his treasure.

2. He Mistakes Play for Partnership

Peter Pan men are fun. They’re spontaneous, charming, and magnetic. But here’s the catch: when the music stops, so does their effort. They love the thrill of chemistry, but disappear when it’s time to build consistency.

3. He Lives in the Land of “Someday”

“Someday I’ll start that business.”
“Someday I’ll settle down.”
“Someday I’ll get serious.”

Peter Pan lives in Neverland, where dreams stay dreams. He talks about growth, but never brings it into reality. If everything he promises is always in the future, it’s time to ask: what is he doing today?

4. Accountability Is Always Someone Else’s Job

Peter Pan men are professional blame-shifters. The work season is busy, his ex was too needy, you’re too demanding, the timing is bad, there’s always a reason he can’t step up, and it’s never his issue. But a man who won’t own his mistakes will never own a marriage.

5. He Confuses Pursuit with Presence

He’s great at the chase: Texting, flirting, showing up when it’s exciting. But once he “has” you, his consistency vanishes. Pursuit is easy. Staying is manhood. Don’t confuse a man who knows how to pursue with one who knows how to stay.

The Truth: Partnership Requires Maturity

Dating a Peter Pan might feel exciting, but it will leave you exhausted. You weren’t made to mother a man. You were made to stand beside a partner who has put childish ways behind him.

Real love doesn’t just entertain you, it grows you. It requires maturity, accountability, and vision. And you deserve nothing less.

✨ This is why I created Last Year Single, to help women stop entertaining Peter Pans, break toxic cycles, and position themselves for grown, godly love that lasts.

🎉 Right now, we’re celebrating our 5-year anniversary with 30 days of specials and our lowest price ever until October 31st. This is your moment to step into maturity in your love life.

👉 Join the Last Year Single program here.

ABOUT JACKIE DORMAN

Jackie Dorman is a relationship coach, matchmaker, bestselling author, and speaker who has helped over 1,600 people get married in just the last four years through her singles program Last Year Single and her proprietary HeartWork process. She calls Austin, Texas home with her husband of 18 years, David. Together they have a beautiful blended family with three adult children and two grandbabies.

as seen and
heard on:

What do you want to read today?

SEARCH

CATEGORIES