How Attachment Style, Anxiety, and Spiritual Pressure Shape What You Think You Want in a Partner

November 24, 2025

Hi, I'm Jackie

I'm the head cheerleader for your love story, your new 'big sis' and wing woman - so if you're new to me, welcome to me, your love life will be better now. 

Most people think the biggest barrier to finding love is a lack of available, high-quality singles.

But after working with thousands of singles as a relationship coach, here’s what I believe is closer to the truth:

Most people are not single because of their standards. They’re single because of their safety strategies.

What looks like “high standards” is often:

  • attachment trauma
  • relationship anxiety
  • religious OCD
  • cultural conditioning
  • internalized fear

The wild part?

Most people don’t even realize it.

So let’s break this down and talk about why modern dating feels harder, scarier, and more confusing than ever and how to finally reset your standards so they’re rooted in your wisdom, not your wounds.

PART 1: When Your Standards Are Really Symptoms

Your “type” might not be based on preference, it might be based on protection.

Your “standards” might not be really be a deregulated nervous system.

Your hyper-specific “outer appearance requirements” might not be about attraction, they might be a way for your brain to create certainty because dating feels unsafe.

Avoidant Attachment

Uses “high standards” as escape routes:

  • “If they’re not perfect, I’m out.”
  • “I need someone who looks exactly like XYZ.”
  • “If I feel too much too soon, something must be wrong.”

This isn’t discernment, it’s disconnection strategies.

Anxious Attachment

Anxious attachment tries to create safety through fantasy.

  • “If I choose right & pick the perfect partner, I’ll finally feel secure.”
  • “If the signs look perfect, maybe they won’t leave.”
  • “If I choose right, I’ll finally feel secure.

Trying to guarantee the outcome before taking the risk isn’t shallow, it’s fear of abandonment.

Disorganized Attachment

This one creates impossible standards to avoid the terror of closeness.

  • “Something feels off.”
  • “I don’t have peace.”

Closeness feels dangerous, so the standards become unattainable.

Religious OCD / Relationship OCD

This is where it gets spiritual-looking but it’s actually anxiety-driven.

  • “What if this isn’t God? I need a new sign every 15 minutes.”
  • “What if I miss my person?”
  • “One wrong date will ruin my destiny.”
  • Thinks feeling uncertain = “God is saying no”

This isn’t discernment or prophetic, it’s hypervigilance wrapped up in a Bible verse.

ROOT TRUTH:

Unrealistic standards are rarely about high expectations.
They’re usually about high levels of fear.

Where This Anxiety Comes From

For most of human history, people chose partners within community, not in isolation.

You married people whose:

  • character
  • reputation
  • family
  • values
  • behavior

were already known by the community around you.

Community filtered your options.
Family modeled connection.
Spiritual community reinforced commitment.

You didn’t need a 47-item checklist because you had a living, breathing safety net.

But today, everything that used to hold dating together has broken down:

The Breakdown of Family

Many adults never saw:

  • healthy communication
  • conflict + repair
  • emotional safety
  • faithful commitment
  • mutual respect
  • secure love

So they build rules instead of using role models.

The Breakdown of Community

Now most people date:

  • alone
  • online
  • in fear
  • without trusted voices
  • without guidance
  • without mirrors

Where there is no community, culture fills the void.

Cultural Standards Replace Real Ones

Now our “type” is shaped by:

  • Instagram aesthetics
  • influencer relationships
  • gym culture
  • romantic fantasies
  • idealized bodies
  • TikTok dating advice
  • curated perfection

Not actual character.

Religious Pressure Makes It Worse

On top of trauma + culture, Christians hear:

  • “Don’t choose wrong.”
  • “Wait for God.”
  • “You must hear perfectly.”
  • “You better not settle.”
  • “Don’t miss your destiny.”

That pressure makes people more anxious, not wiser.

Bottom Line

Broken family → no modeling
Broken community → no support
Cultural fantasy → perfectionism
Religious pressure → fear of misstepping


This is why modern Christians struggle so deeply with unrealistic standards.

It’s not your fault.
But it is something you can heal.

Godly Standards vs. Trauma Standards vs. Anxiety Standards

Now that we know where all this comes from, here’s how to tell the difference:

GODLY STANDARDS

Feel: Calm, grounded, consistent, peaceful
Focus on:

  • character
  • kindness
  • emotional health
  • integrity
  • consistency

These guide you. They don’t control you.

TRAUMA STANDARDS

Feel: Rigid, defensive, reactive, suspicious
Sound like:

  • “Never again will I…”
  • “If they do or say this ONE thing, I’m out.”

These aren’t wrong, they’re just unhealed.

ANXIETY STANDARDS

Feel: Panicked, perfectionistic, pressured
Sound like:

  • “I need certainty before I’m vulnerable.”
  • “They have to be exactly this height/look/style.”

This isn’t wise because what if you find your “list” person but you still don’t have peace?

THE LITMUS TEST

Ask yourself:

Does this non-negotiable GUIDE me, or PROTECT me?
Does it come from PEACE or PRESSURE?
Does it honor my FUTURE or fear of my PAST?
Does it create CONNECTION or DISTANCE?

Listen to your body, your nervous system will tell you the truth.

FINAL WORD

Your love story isn’t delayed because your standards are too high.

It’s delayed because your standards are trying to keep you safe, not help you choose wisely.

Healing your attachment style, clearing religious anxiety, and reconnecting to healthy community will completely transform what you expect and what you attract.

Your standards won’t get lower.
They’ll get truer.

Your relationships won’t necessarily get easier. They’ll get healthier.

And your love story won’t just happen. It will be accelerated.

If you’d like relationship coaching so you can get help with all of this, join Last Year Single.

ABOUT JACKIE DORMAN

Jackie Dorman is a relationship coach, matchmaker, bestselling author, and speaker who has helped over 1,600 people get married in just the last four years through her singles program Last Year Single and her proprietary HeartWork process. She calls Austin, Texas home with her husband of 18 years, David. Together they have a beautiful blended family with three adult children and two grandbabies.

as seen and
heard on:

What do you want to read today?

SEARCH

CATEGORIES